Thursday, June 25, 2009

Pizza Italiano is CLOSED!

Joe(y) just reported that Jimmy Shover's Pizza Italiano Restaurant at 5150 Normandy Boulevard has CLOSED! Going by the single review on Google, we'd have to say we aren't surprised....

"Rated 1.0 out of 5.0 UCK!!‎ by Nsanebiatch‎ - Mar 10, 2009....."Unsanitary and unfriendly".‎"
You can also go ahead and throw away that buy one get one free entree coupon from your Entertainment Book, it's of no use now.

14 comments:

Norm Stovall said...

I actually liked that place. =(

Anonymous said...

Yeah. It wasn't great but it certainly wasn't yuck. Too bad it closed.

Anonymous said...

it closed due to the economy. the food was great. they even had the clean plate award many times just watch 47 news on thursday at 10:00 i'm sure you can find it. we have been eating their for decades.we will miss the place.

Anonymous said...

i loved that place. had the best eggplant parm of all the pizza italianos in town

Anonymous said...

Is this web site reliable or just a forum for one sided non researched information. How do you quote one source and only say negative things about a business instead of doing your homework and finding out the real reason a business has closed. There is more than one side to every story and yours about Pizza Italiano seems to be written to be mean and sets a bad standard if this site might ever go anywhere. With a story so negative and slanted this web site will probably be the next business in Jacksonville to close

Anonymous said...

pizza italiano i miss all your home made dressings your should write a recipe book... helen

Anonymous said...

Does any one know how to contact jimmy the owner want the blue cheese recipe and alfredo... Scott

Anonymous said...

How long has this site been up?
Who owns it and who are the writers?

Cheetarah said...

I had a terribly bad experience there a few months ago. Whoever that pear-shaped guy who worked there is..... He is rude and very flamboyant. Try casa Dora downtown for some really good Italian.

Editor Marily said...

I love Jacksonville Confidential, it will never "go out of business".

The Editor said...

Mmm Casa Dora. Good call!

I own/write this blog and if you don't like it, don't read it.

And thanks for reading. ;)

Eggman said...

Ew! "enjoying" the eggplant Parmesan? I doubt that, I ordered it one time and it was basically a greasy pile of mush. No tears shed here over the closing of this dump. I hear it's converting to a roach motel.

Anonymous said...

Quoting - " Anonymous said...
Does any one know how to contact jimmy the owner want the blue cheese recipe and alfredo... Scott

12:58 PM"

Yes. His number is 1-800-555-FAGG


.....lion-o

The Editor said...

Lol! That was funny lion-o.